ONEWAY Cafe and Pizza
Discover a slice of heaven at ONEWAY Cafe and Pizza, an inviting pizza restaurant located at 11 Mulberry St, Middletown, NY 10940. With its charming atmosphere and friendly service, ONEWAY is quickly becoming a local favorite for both casual diners and families alike.
Step inside and be greeted with a warm ambiance, accented by cheerful decor that sets the stage for a delightful dining experience. The inviting smell of freshly baked pizza fills the air, making it nearly impossible to resist the array of mouthwatering options available. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheese pizza or something more adventurous, ONEWAY has something to tempt every palate.
The menu boasts an impressive blend of delightful choices—from their children’s menu, featuring a Fluffy Pancake for just $2.00 or a Little Sunshine breakfast of 1 Egg, 1 Pancake, and 1 Slice of Bacon for $5.00, perfect for your little ones to enjoy a hearty start to the day. For something more savory, check out the Chicken Quesadilla, loaded with delectable cheddar and mozzarella cheese for just $12.75. Indulge in their Chicken Wings, available in either hot or mild, which come in a generous portion of 10 for only $15.00. Don't forget to explore their tempting dessert section, where you can finish off your meal with a slice of rich Pineapple Cheesecake for $5.99 or experience the sweet joy of Tiramisu for $7.75.
What truly sets ONEWAY Cafe and Pizza apart is the heartfelt approach of its owners. Customers rave about the warmth and hospitality that greet them the moment they arrive. One satisfied diner shared, “We weren't planning on stopping at this restaurant but God had different plans... the food was spectacular and their Faith was inspiring.” It’s this kind of genuine connection that transforms a simple meal into a cherished memory.
Whether you are planning a casual outing with friends or a family dinner, ONEWAY offers a cozy environment where great food and friendly conversation flourish. Many regulars, including Latoya B., couldn’t resist returning multiple times in the same week, enjoying everything from pizza to dessert—"I had to take the rest of the food home," she admits, echoing the sentiments of many who appreciate the generous portions.
In a world where dining often becomes just about food, ONEWAY Cafe and Pizza stands out as a location where community, flavor, and hospitality collide delightfully. Make sure to stop by, and experience firsthand why so many consider ONEWAY not just a stop for a meal, but a destination for enjoyable moments and heartwarming connections!
To contact ONEWAY, feel free to reach out at +1 845-239-4171.
28 Reviews
15 Oct 2025
22 Sep 2025
18 Sep 2025
02 Sep 2025
01 Sep 2025
02 Aug 2025
10 Jul 2025
Square Pizza
Restaurant La Table du Lavoir - Les Sources de Caudalie
La Bersagliera
Alley Cat Pizza
El Quemao
Join the ONEWAY Cafe and Pizza Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.